Identification of T Cell Senescence As a Cell Fate Limiting the Antitumor Activity of 41BB-Costimulated CART Cells

Despite the high initial responses to chimeric antigen receptor T (CART) cell therapy, most patients relapse within the first 1-2 years. T cell quality influences the success of CART cell therapies greatly, and T cells from cancer patients are prone to transition into dysfunctional states, such as exhaustion or senescence. The role of exhaustion in CART cell failures has been studied extensively; however, the role of T cell senescence has remained mostly unexplored. In this study, we aimed to determine the development of CART cell senescence and its impact on CART therapeutic efficacy.

First, we studied the development of CART cell senescence using an in vitro model to induce CART cell dysfunction. Here, we cyclically activated CD19-directed chimeric antigen receptor T (CART19) cells (either costimulated via 4-1BB (BBζ) or CD28 (28ζ)). Activation cycles are designed to mimic recurrent activation of CART cells to study the impact of T cell activation on CART cell fates throughout treatment. We added a rest time in between activation cycles to focus on senesced CART cell populations since, unlike exhaustion, senescence is irreversible even after rest. We examined CART immunophenotype, cell cycle regulators, transcriptomic profile, senescence marker gene expressions and T cell effector functions on days 0 (D0-T cell), 8 (D8-baseline CART), and 15 (D15-CART cell after one activation/rest cycles).

Following an activation/rest cycle, T cell exhaustion markers CTLA4, LAG3, and PD1 returned to basal levels after an initial increase due to activation, while only TIM-3 levels remained elevated (BBζ: p=0.0090, 28ζ: p=0.0394). Increased TIM-3 expression is associated with T cell senescence, which prompted us to further investigate the development of a senescence phenotype. We found a prominent T cell senescence phenotype in BBζ compared to 28ζ, as evident by increased expression of p53 (BBζ: p=0.0248), p21 (BBζ: p=0.0483), CD27 (BBζ: p=0.0080), CD28 (BBζ: p=0.0327), uPAR (BBζ vs. 28ζ: p<0.0001), and KLRG1 (BBζ vs. 28ζ: p=0.0029) in recurrently activated-rested CART cells.

Next, we evaluated the transcriptomic signature of recurrently activated-rested CART cells. Gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA) indicated enrichment of gene sets related to senescent T cells as well as senMayo, a novel gene set which is reported to be selectively enriched in senescing cells or tissues, in BBζ, but not in 28ζ, compared to T cell D0 or in BBζ D15 compared to 28ζ D15 (p=0.00014 and p=0.089, respectively). MYC-related gene sets were found to be significantly enriched in recurrently activated/rested BBζ and depleted in 28ζ (p<0.1). MYC expression is increased in BBζ (p= 0.0010) while decreased in 28ζ (p=0.0036) upon recurrent activation and is higher in BBζ (D8: p=0.0018, D15: p= 0.0022) compared to 28ζ at indicated time points by qPCR. Given these results, we induced senescence in CART cells using two alternative strategies: MYC-T58A activation (oncogene-induced senescence) and irradiation. Senescence induced by MYC-T58A overexpression ameliorated only BBζ killing (p=0.0057), whereas senescence induced by irradiation improved 28ζ killing (p= 0.0086), indicating versatile impact of senescence on treatment outcome diverse CART cell therapies.

Finally, analysis with two independent patient data sets correlated the emergence of senescence with contradicting clinical outcomes to BBζ and 28ζ treatments. The presence of senescent 28ζ cells in the peripheral blood of 28ζ-treated patients was reported to be associated with complete response in the clinic in an independent analysis. In another cohort, 28ζ-treated patients with higher senescence score were correlated with longer disease-free survival (p=0.0029), while senMayo gene set enrichment in BBζ-treated patients was associated with non-response in the clinic (p=0.014). In the same cohort, MYC-related gene sets—the same genes sets enriched in our recurrently activated/rested BBζ—are also enriched in nonresponsive BBζ-treated patients.

In summary, our study indicates that (i) CART cells are susceptible to a state of senescence, as demonstrated using three independent approaches (repeated activation/rest, irradiation, and MYC modulation), (ii) CART senescence is more prominent in BBζ than 28ζ, and (iii) senescence is associated with worse outcomes following BBζ but not 28ζ treatment.